Tag: 2024

  • Shabana Mahmood – 2024 Swearing in Speech as Lord Chancellor

    Shabana Mahmood – 2024 Swearing in Speech as Lord Chancellor

    The speech made by Shabana Mahmood, the Lord Chancellor, on 16 July 2024.

    My Lords, Ladies, friends, colleagues.

    Lady Chief Justice, thank you for that welcome.

    May I also take the opportunity to welcome Richard Hermer KC as he takes his oath today as Attorney General.

    Mr Attorney, your deep expertise will be of enormous value to the Government…

    And I know already that we will be allies to one another in our roles.

    So too Sarah Sackman, who takes her oath as Solicitor General today.

    Madam Solicitor, it took me 14 years from becoming a Member of Parliament, to serving in government.

    You’ve done it in 5 days.

    That is a fitting tribute to the talent and dedication you have shown to upholding the rule of law throughout your career.

    I look forward to working closely with you in the months and years ahead.

    I must say what an honour it is to take my own oath as Lord Chancellor today.

    There once was a little girl in Small Heath, one of the poorest areas of Birmingham…

    Who worked behind the till in her parents’ corner shop.

    Yes, she took great inspiration from Kavanagh QC, that brilliant barrister with working class roots…

    But she never dared to dream she would be sitting before you all today…

    Counted among the holders of this ancient role.

    So believe me, I know: along with some fairly idiosyncratic outfits, comes great responsibility.

    I hold this office in the very highest regard.

    I do so not just as a former barrister, but as the child of immigrants.

    My parents weren’t steeped in Magna Carta, Habeas Corpus and the Bill of Rights – as I would one day be.

    But they did have a strong sense, arriving here in the UK from rural Kashmir, that this country was different:

    That there are rules, some written and some not, that we abide by:

    Queues must be observed, near religiously…

    Weather must be discussed, pretty compulsively…

    But also, more seriously, there are institutions, like our courts, that are incorruptible…

    And that, in this country, no-one is above the law, not even the government, and none are below it either.

    To have so many of my family here today, stretching the limits of my guestlist quota, means a great deal to me.

    And while I have the chance:

    Mum, Dad, can I just say: jazakallah khair, thank you.

    Instilled as a child, my respect for the rule of law grew stronger as I grew older:

    First, studying law at university…

    Then, in practice.

    And it was never felt more keenly than when appearing before a member of our fiercely independent judiciary…

    I can now confirm that the same tingle of nerves never goes away…

    Even when you’re the Lord Chancellor appearing alongside the Lady Chief Justice.

    I’d also like to thank the man who set me on my way in the law, to whom I will forever be indebted:

    My pupil master – William Audland KC – who is squeezed between members of my very large, extended family in the gallery today.

    I understand it’s customary for a new Lord Chancellor to draw parallels with an eminent predecessor when they take their oath…

    I had a good old look around for a Lord Chancellor who looks or sounds like me, but drew something of a blank.

    That’s right, folks. There wasn’t a single Brummie.

    There was one who leapt out though, whose example I hope to follow:

    Frederick Elwyn-Jones.

    We share a few things in common:

    Our Inn of Court – Gray’s.

    Our political party – Labour.

    As a barrister he had a passion for human rights, and was a prosecutor at Nuremberg.

    I – and this government – will follow his example in defending the international rule of law and upholding human rights.

    And we will certainly not be seeking to extricate ourselves from the landmark human rights convention drawn up in the aftermath of that war.

    Elwyn-Jones served as Lord Chancellor for 5 years between 1974 and 1979.

    By recent standards, that counts as an eternity.

    I certainly hope to emulate his longevity.

    It is said that he was the first Welsh speaking Lord Chancellor for centuries.

    I wonder what he would’ve made of the first Lord Chancellor to speak Urdu.

    I’ve carried the weight of many identities in this career…

    It is a privilege, but also a burden…

    I am always aware that, for the good of those who come afterwards, getting this wrong – I usually use less temperate language – isn’t an option.

    But getting it right can open doors.

    When I walked into the Ministry of Justice for the first time…

    10 days ago, though it feels like 10 months…

    I walked past the portraits of my recent predecessors:

    The good, the bad and the ugly.

    They all looked alike, and not much like me.

    So, at the very least, I hope my appointment shows the next little girl…

    In Small Heath, or wherever she may be…

    That, in this country, even the oldest offices in the land are within reach of us all.

    The responsibilities of this ancient office are as real today as they ever were.

    The rule of law is more than an ideal.

    It is more than a vague concept, employed only by academic lawyers…

    It is the most enduring of British values.

    We are a nation that believes in due process…

    We are a nation where the law has the final word, not the mob…

    And we are a nation where our disputes, however fierce, are resolved by debate and argument.

    For politicians of all stripes, the law looms large.

    As parliamentarians, we are not only advocates for our constituents, we are legislators…

    Charged with making and shaping the laws our society will live by.

    But it is our independent courts who must then interpret and enforce those laws, with no hint of political interference.

    And I take seriously my oath to defend your independence…

    You are the guardians of the rule of law and at the heart of our legal prestige.

    It is a job that requires deep expertise, knowledge and integrity…

    As you make decisions on some of the most difficult ethical and technical issues of our time…

    You must be free to make them without political pressure and undue influence.

    You must never be subjected to the kinds of attacks that we saw in recent years…

    When newspaper headlines branded those who uphold the law: “enemies of the people”.

    I will be a champion for the rule of law, and our judiciary, inside Cabinet and in our government, at home and abroad.

    I will say ‘no’ where ‘no’ is warranted…

    Even if, at times, I frustrate my ministerial colleagues in doing so.

    After all, that frustration is not a failure of our system, but an essential feature of it.

    The final part of my oath places a duty on me to ensure the provision of resources for the courts…

    Which is where safeguarding access to justice truly begins.

    I must first take the opportunity to acknowledge the complete dedication shown by those who work in our courts and tribunals…

    And how hard you have worked to recover from the effects of the pandemic.

    I know the challenges faced in our courts, and across the justice system, are very deep indeed.

    I hope you saw last week, in the emergency measures that we have taken to address the prisons crisis…

    That I will do what it takes to ensure justice can be done in this country.

    But I know there is so much more that must be addressed:

    Justice delayed is all too often justice denied…

    And this has proved particularly true of women and girls who are the victims of violence and abuse.

    So we must work hard across the justice system to ensure cases are heard sooner and justice is done in a timely way.

    We must also continue the modernisation of our courts and tribunals – criminal, civil and family.

    And we need legal aid that is fit for the needs of the modern world.

    I don’t pretend that any of these have easy answers…

    Nor that everything will be solved quickly.

    But I can say that I will fight for our justice system…

    And that I intend to be in that fight for the long haul.

    Chapter 4 Verse 135 of the Quran reads:

    O ye who believe!

    Stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to Allah…

    Even as against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin…

    And whether it be (against) rich or poor:

    For Allah can best protect both.

    This is the fundamental articulation of how we, as Muslims, view justice in how we deal with the world.

    It places justice above all else.

    Upholding justice is the ideal that has guided my life.

    It ties together both where my family came from, and the great nation we chose to call home.

    And so I will fight for it, every day…

    With the fierceness of many generations of small but mighty Kashmiri women…

    Inherited from my mother.

    And I will pursue the hard work of rebuilding our justice system…

    With the dogged determination I inherited from my dad…

    Who came to this country to make a new life for his family – and never took “no” for an answer.

    To swear this oath today is the greatest honour of my life.

    But, more even than that, it is the greatest of responsibilities.

    I will work tirelessly to discharge its duties and to defend justice.

    Thank you.

  • John Healey – 2024 Statement on the Armed Forces Review

    John Healey – 2024 Statement on the Armed Forces Review

    The statement made by John Healey, the Secretary of State for Defence, on 16 July 2024.

    At the start of a new era for Britain, we need a new era for defence. Hollowed-out armed forces, procurement waste and neglected morale cannot continue. Meanwhile, we need to be clear eyed about the threats we face, with the world becoming more volatile and technology changing the nature of warfare.

    In response, our armed forces need to be better ready to fight, more integrated and more innovative. We need clearer accountability, faster delivery, less waste and better value for money.

    The Review will ensure that Defence is central to the future security of Britain and to its economic growth and prosperity.

    This new era requires a new type of review that moves at pace. The Prime Minister and I will therefore draw on both external military, industrial and foreign policy experts, and those from inside Government, to help set the path for Britain’s defence for the next decade. Together, we will make Britain secure at home and strong abroad.

  • Keir Starmer – 2024 Statement on the Armed Forces Review

    Keir Starmer – 2024 Statement on the Armed Forces Review

    The statement made by Keir Starmer, the Prime Minister, on 16 July 2024.

    We live in a more dangerous and volatile world. My government will forge a new clear-eyed approach to our national defences, equipping us to tackle international threats head-on while keeping the British people safe and secure.

    I promised the British people I would deliver the change needed to take our country forward, and I promised action not words. That’s why one of my first acts since taking office is to launch our Strategic Defence Review. We will make sure our hollowed out armed forces are bolstered and respected, that defence spending is responsibly increased, and that our country has the capabilities needed to ensure the UK’s resilience for the long term.

  • PRESS RELEASE : UK and others invoke Vienna Mechanism on political prisoners in Belarus – Joint Statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : UK and others invoke Vienna Mechanism on political prisoners in Belarus – Joint Statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    The press release issued by the Foreign Office on 12 July 2024.

    UK and 37 other countries invoke the OSCE Vienna Mechanism in respect of serious human rights concerns in Belarus, including torture, physical or sexual violence, lack of basic medical care and privacy, lack of a fair trial, psychological pressure and discrimination.

    I am delivering this statement on behalf of the following participating States, who are members of the informal Group of Friends of Democratic Belarus: Belgium, Bulgaria, Canada, Croatia, Czechia, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxemburg, Montenegro, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Spain, Sweden, the United Kingdom, the United States, and my own country, Slovenia.

    The following participating States are also joining this statement: Albania, Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Liechtenstein, Moldova, North Macedonia, Switzerland and Ukraine.

    In the 1991 Moscow Document, OSCE participating States declared that commitments undertaken in the field of the human dimension are matters of direct and legitimate concern to all participating States and do not belong exclusively to the internal affairs of the State concerned.

    In keeping with this commitment, we wish to express our deep concern regarding the severe human rights violations and abuses occurring in Belarus. These were documented by rapporteur Professor Hervé Ascensio after 38 participating States invoked the Moscow Mechanism on 23 March 2023. His report, introduced to the Permanent Council on 11 May 2023, described repression designed to hinder any form of opposition, which led to waves of arrests on political grounds, targeting demonstrators, journalists, other media workers, human rights defenders, representatives of trade unions, lawyers, political opponents, and those expressing their opposition to the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, among others. The report recommended the release of all political prisoners and the reform of existing laws in Belarus to bring national criminal legislation and the code of administrative offences in full compliance with international norms and standards.

    Regrettably, Belarus has followed neither these recommendations nor a similar call for the release of all the political prisoners issued by 17 UN experts. Other reports from various UN bodies and NGOs have confirmed that the human rights situation in Belarus, in particular the situation of political prisoners, has continued to deteriorate.

    To date, six of these individuals have died in detention: Vitold Ashurak, Mikhaïl Klimovich, Ales Pushkin, Vadzim Khrasko, Ihar Lednik and Aliaksandr Kulinich. Many others are being held incommunicado.

    Experts have documented that the estimated 1400 political prisoners currently in detention in Belarus experience torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, acts of physical or sexual violence, lack of basic medical care and privacy, lack of a fair trial, psychological pressure and discrimination, with their cells and clothing marked with yellow tags.

    While we take note of the recent release of several political prisoners, we consider unsatisfactory the Belarusian authorities’ response to the Moscow Mechanism report of 11 May 2023 and, given our ongoing concerns about developments over the past 12 months, our countries are now invoking the Vienna Mechanism, along with the requirements of Belarus under that Mechanism.

    The full text of the letter of invocation, including the names of several persons whose situation is particularly critical, will be circulated to all participating States. But I would like to read the questions it contains.

    Since the release of the Moscow Mechanism report on Belarus, on 11 May 2023:

    1. What steps have Belarusian authorities taken to ensure that persons deprived of liberty on politically motivated grounds are treated with humanity and respect for their inherent dignity?
    2. What steps have Belarusian authorities taken to release political prisoners on humanitarian grounds, including those with serious health issues or chronic conditions, people with disabilities, minors, older persons, people with children or single parents? What update can be provided on the prisoners mentioned in the letter?
    3. What steps have Belarusian authorities taken to ensure that specific needs of female detainees, including psychological and medical needs, are taken into account?
    4. What steps have been taken to ensure that all detainees have access to necessary and appropriate medication and medical care?
    5. What steps have been taken to ensure decent conditions of detention for all prisoners? Do authorities in charge of detention facilities provide all prisoners, without exception, with blankets, mattresses, and sanitary articles? Which measures have been taken against overcrowding?
    6. In the light of documented cases of ill-treatment which may in some instances amount to torture, including sleep deprivation, what steps have Belarusian authorities taken to investigate all allegations and to prevent such treatment in the future?
    7. What criteria govern the use of solitary confinement, punishment cells and cell-like premises? As these have been identified as potentially inhumane conditions of detention, what steps have been taken to reduce their use?
    8. What steps have been taken to ensure that every prisoner has access to legal counsel of their own choosing, to effective remedies and a fair trial? What steps have been taken to ensure that prisoners are able to maintain contact with family members?
    9. Will Belarusian authorities refrain from implementing the procedure of deprivation of citizenship of Belarusian nationals living abroad as a sanction for so called “participation in extremist activity or infliction of grievous harm to the interests of the Republic of Belarus”?
    10. Will Belarus end repressive measures taken against family members in order to exert pressure on defendants and political prisoners?
    11. As a measure of transparency, would Belarus allow visits to detention facilities by representatives of international organizations, including the International Committee of the Red Cross, and foreign States in detention facilities?

    We expect to receive information in response to these serious concerns in writing within ten days, in accordance with the Vienna Mechanism.

    I request this statement and the corresponding invocation letter be attached to the journal of the day.

  • PRESS RELEASE : 29th anniversary of the Srebrenica Genocide – UK statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : 29th anniversary of the Srebrenica Genocide – UK statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    The press release issued by the Foreign Office on 12 July 2024.

    Ambassador Holland remembers the victims of the Srebrenica genocide in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and pays tribute to the courage and resilience shown by families and survivors.

    Thank you, Mr Chair.

    Today we remember the victims of the Srebrenica genocide in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and honour the survivors. This year we are marking 11 July more formally for the first time as the International Day of Reflection and Commemoration of the 1995 Genocide in Srebrenica, following the adoption of a UN General Assembly resolution on 23 May. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia found that several individuals were guilty of genocide in Srebrenica. Acknowledgement of that fact should not be a cause for tension and division. Rather, it is a basis on which true reconciliation can be achieved.

    Mr Chair, 29 years ago in Srebrenica, genocide took place in Europe for the first time since 1945. It claimed the lives of over 8,000 mostly Muslim men and boys, and led to the displacement of over 20,000 women and children who were forcibly expelled from their homes. We honour the memory of those killed, and pay tribute to the extraordinary courage and resilience shown by their families and by survivors. We stand with the families in their ongoing fight for justice.

    The UK is committed to supporting Bosnia and Herzegovina in its efforts to build a secure, stable, inclusive society, and heal the fractures caused by conflict. It is regrettable that we continue to see divisive and dangerous nationalist rhetoric, secessionist moves, and open challenges to the constitutional order established by the Dayton Peace Agreement. The UK is committed to a single, sovereign Bosnia and Herzegovina, and will continue to take action in support of that. We also continue to urge political leaders to condemn any glorification of the perpetrators of war crimes, and to take action against genocide denial.

    Mr Chair, as was the case in 2022 and 2023, we are marking this date in the shadow of Russia’s illegal and unprovoked war of aggression against Ukraine. We must learn the lessons of history. Terrible events such as the genocide at Srebrenica show the consequences of inaction. We owe it to the victims to create societies that are stable, inclusive and cohesive, and to fight against prejudice, hatred, fear and division wherever we find it. Remaining true to our shared commitment to the concept of comprehensive security, articulated by the Helsinki principles and central to membership of the OSCE, is the best way to do this. The greatest tribute we can give to those who lost their lives is to do everything we can to prevent such a horrific crime from ever being repeated.

    Thank you, Mr Chair.

  • PRESS RELEASE : New UK support for up to 150,000 vulnerable Sudanese refugees [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : New UK support for up to 150,000 vulnerable Sudanese refugees [July 2024]

    The press release issued by the Foreign Office on 12 July 2024.

    The UK government announces a £2 million package to support up to 150,000 Sudanese refugees in Libya fleeing violence.

    • UK to contribute £2 million support to refugees in Libya fleeing violence in Darfur, Sudan
    • funding will support much-needed emergency health, water and sanitation services
    • alongside international partners aid will deliver support to up to 150,000 refugees

    International Development Minister Anneliese Dodds has today [Friday 12 July] pledged new UK aid funding to provide life-saving assistance to up to 150,000 Sudanese refugees who are fleeing escalating violence in Darfur.

    It’s estimated that more than 2 million people have fled Sudan due to the violence which erupted following a coup in April last year, including more than 1,200 people entering Libya daily.

    This forms part of the government’s commitment to work with international partners to address the humanitarian crises which lead people to flee their homes, and to strengthen support for refugees in their home region.

    This £2 million package will go towards the humanitarian response in the hard-to-reach Alkufra region, where the UN estimates up to 45,000 refugees are currently in desperate need of support.

    Health provision in Alkufra is minimal and was struggling even before the humanitarian crisis. Under the strain of thousands of refugees, in need of medical assistance, the system is now on the verge of collapse.

    Alongside international partners, this funding will help deliver much-needed emergency health, water, sanitation, hygiene, and child protection services to an estimated 150,000 individuals taking refuge in Eastern Libya, as well as the communities hosting them.

    The Minister of State for Development, Anneliese Dodds, said:

    The UK is committed to delivering life-saving aid to some of the world’s most vulnerable people, including children, as they flee violence in war-torn Sudan.

    Alongside our international partners, this support in Libya will deliver much-needed water and emergency health, sanitation and hygiene services to these displaced refugees.

  • PRESS RELEASE : Keir Starmer meeting with President Erdoğan of Turkey [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : Keir Starmer meeting with President Erdoğan of Turkey [July 2024]

    The press release issued by 10 Downing Street on 11 July 2024.

    The Prime Minister met President Erdoğan of Turkey at the NATO summit this afternoon.

    The Prime Minister welcomed the deep ties between the two countries, and the significant contribution that Turkish communities provide to the culture and economy of the UK. He said Turkey was a hugely important NATO ally, and that the UK wants to deepen the bilateral relationship.

    The President discussed his aspiration to strengthen the bilateral relationship across trade, tourism, defence, counter-terrorism, energy and the economy.

    They discussed Ukraine and welcomed the enhanced support provided by this NATO summit.

    On the Middle East, the Prime Minister said he wanted to see an immediate ceasefire to let the hostages out and increase aid in.

  • PRESS RELEASE : Keir Starmer meeting with President Yoon of the Republic of Korea [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : Keir Starmer meeting with President Yoon of the Republic of Korea [July 2024]

    The press release issued by 10 Downing Street on 11 July 2024.

    The Prime Minister met President Yoon of the Republic of Korea at the NATO summit today.

    The President congratulated the Prime Minister on his election victory and thanked the UK once more for hosting him on an excellent State Visit last year.

    Discussing current geopolitical challenges, they agreed that the Republic of Korea is a key NATO partner and we must continue to work closely together on defence, because Euro-Atlantic and Indo-Pacific security are indivisible.

    The two leaders remarked that the UK and the Republic of Korea share a strategically important partnership and agreed there are further opportunities to develop stronger ties between our countries – building on the Downing Street Accord signed in November.

    They looked forward to deepening our relationship across a number of issues including even deeper cooperation on security and defence, as well as further collaboration on green energy, trade, and artificial intelligence.

    The President finished by wishing England good luck in the final of the Euros on Sunday.

  • PRESS RELEASE : First meeting between the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and the Tánaiste marks renewed commitment to UK-Irish relations [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : First meeting between the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and the Tánaiste marks renewed commitment to UK-Irish relations [July 2024]

    The press release issued by the Northern Ireland Office on 11 July 2024.

    The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP, and the Tánaiste, Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister for Defence, Micheál Martin TD, met this evening [Thursday 11 July] at Hillsborough Castle.

    The discussions marked the first official engagement between the two, and comes as both the UK and Irish Governments pledge a reset in relations. They were joined by Fleur Anderson MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Northern Ireland Office.

    The Secretary of State reiterated the UK Government’s responsibility as co-signatory to the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, emphasising the importance of maintaining political stability and peace in Northern Ireland. The meeting highlighted the shared goals of the UK and Irish Governments and the importance of continued cooperation and dialogue in future.

    The Secretary of State also stressed the need to address the legacy of the past in a way that is supported by victims and survivors and is compliant with human rights obligations. Mr Benn welcomed the news that the Irish Government has committed to assisting with the Omagh Bombing Inquiry and encouraged them to take all steps necessary to facilitate its work.

    The Secretary of State pledged to continue  implementing the Windsor Framework in good faith, protecting the UK internal market and supporting Northern Ireland’s economy to thrive in the longer term.

    Speaking afterwards, The Secretary of State said: 

    “It was a pleasure to meet the Tánaiste to discuss the UK Government’s commitment to economic growth, peace and stability in Northern Ireland, and to foster renewed, close relations with our nearest neighbour.

    “As co-signatory of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, I reiterated the UK Government’s commitment to work with the Irish Government for the betterment of the people of Northern Ireland.

    “Our relationship with Ireland is of great importance and I look forward to continuing to work closely with the Irish Government to reset and strengthen the relationship between our two countries.”

  • PRESS RELEASE : President Putin’s preconditions are incompatible with the OSCE Decalogue – UK statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    PRESS RELEASE : President Putin’s preconditions are incompatible with the OSCE Decalogue – UK statement to the OSCE [July 2024]

    The press release issued by the Foreign Office on 11 July 2024.

    Ambassador Holland sets out how President Putin’s preconditions for negotiations with Ukraine flagrantly violate OSCE principles.

    Thank you, Madam Chair.  Last month, President Putin delivered a statement to senior Russian officials on the settlement of his war in Ukraine.  He did so as leaders from around the world prepared to travel to Switzerland for the Peace Summit to discuss the foundations of a sustainable peace in Ukraine.

    It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the statement, and its timing, was an unsuccessful attempt to try to undermine the Peace Summit.  But since the proposals and themes in it continue to be repeated, we in this room should assess and judge them against the principles guiding relations between participating States – also known as the Decalogue – since these are the foundational principles of this organisation to which we all committed in the interests of our shared security.

    President Putin stated that there was no plan to storm Kyiv.  In his words, this was “nothing else but an operation to coerce the Ukrainian regime into peace”.  This is in direct contravention of Article Two of the Decalogue. This says: “No such threat or use of force will be employed as a means of settling disputes”. Madam Chair, peace cannot be achieved down the barrel of a gun.

    Among the preconditions for beginning peace negotiations stated in the speech are that Ukraine withdraws its troops completely from Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia oblasts. These are all regions that, in addition to Crimea, fall within Ukraine’s internationally recognised borders.  Article Three of the Decalogue says States should “refrain from any demand for, or act of, seizure and usurpation of part or all of the territory of any participating State.”  And Article Four says they should “refrain from making each other’s territory the object of military occupation or other direct or indirect measures of force”.

    Another of Russia’s conditions for peace is that Ukraine “abandons its plans to join NATO”.  Article One of the Decalogue on sovereign equality provides for: “the right to be or not to be a party to treaties of alliance.”

    Madam Chair, there are many more such examples, not to mention factual inaccuracies.  The point is that this set of proposals is incompatible with the principles which we have all agreed to abide by, including the imperialistic threat that “Ukraine’s existence in the future” depends on its response to Russian aggression. No matter what our geography or political allegiances are, we should all be deeply concerned at how seriously Russia treats its commitments when those commitments become inconvenient.

    It is for Ukraine to determine its own path to peace.  The only peace in Ukraine that will last is one that respects the UN Charter and the OSCE’s principles, a point the global community underlined in Switzerland.  If President Putin wants to deliver that peace, he can do so today by bringing Russia back into alignment with the OSCE Decalogue, which Russia helped draft, and withdrawing from Ukraine.

    Thank you.